Andy Richter

Ben Higgenbottom

Amy Poehler

Bessie Higgenbottom

Matt Besser

Hippie / Anton / Judge / Council Prez / Emcee / Fancy Rich Lady

Dee Bradley Baker

Happy

Jessica DiCicco

Gwen

Megan Cavanagh

Hillary Higgenbottom

Grey DeLisle

Portia Gibbons

Sarah Thyre

Mrs. Gibbons

Dannah Feinglass Phirman

Penny

Don Newhouse

Driver 2 (voice)