Jonathan Roumie

Jesus (voice)

Yvonne Orji

Pigeon (voice)

Paul Walter Hauser

Sheep (voice)

Kellen Erskine

Other Sheep

Romy Fay

Abby (voice)

Jude Zarzaur

Joshua (voice)

Zehra Fazal

Eema (voice)

Danny Nucci

Abba (voice)

Banks Pierce

Hilarius Maximus-a Roman (voice)

Julian Grant

Cyrius (voice)

Elizabeth Tabish

Mary Magdalene (voice)

Omid Abtahi

Kato the Augur (voice)

Nick Chinlund

Apple Vendor (voice)

Noah James

Andrew (voice)

Anjelah Johnson-Reyes

Raven (voice)

Jordin Sparks

Fish (voice)

Joey Vahedi

Thomas (voice)

Yasmine Al-Bustami

Ramah (voice)

Nene Nwoko

Wasp (voice)

Panta Mosleh

Eliza (voice)

Annie Korzen

Dinah (voice)

Brandon Potter

Quintus (voice)

Natalie Lashkari

Yael (voice)

Zoe Lashkari

Adinah (voice)

George H. Xanthis

John (voice)

Paras Patel

Matthew (voice)

Amir Levy

Ofe (voice)

Mark Harelik

Rabbi Josiah (voice)

Anat Cogan

Fruit Merchant (voice)

Dan Istrate

Stranger (voice)

Assaf Cohen

Vendor (voice)

Melissa Shoshahi

Yael's Mom (voice)

Debi Derryberry

Chicken (voice)

Holly A. Franklin

Other Sheep

Piter Marek

Vendor (voice)

Michelle Azar

Passerby (voice)

Charles Marina

Hungry Man (voice)

Jill Holden

Neighbor (voice)

Matthew Jayson Cwern

Tired Roman (voice)

Max Giorgi

Centurion (voice)

Ninaad Vaidya

Passerby (voice)

Sandra Saad

Mother of Hungry Child (voice)