Andrew Garfield

Detective Jeb Pyre

Sam Worthington

Ron Lafferty

Daisy Edgar-Jones

Brenda Lafferty

Denise Gough

Dianna Lafferty

Wyatt Russell

Dan Lafferty

Billy Howle

Allen Lafferty

Chloe Pirrie

Matilda Lafferty

Seth Numrich

Robin Lafferty

Adelaide Clemens

Rebecca Pyre

Rory Culkin

Samuel Lafferty

Gil Birmingham

Detective Bill Taba

Megan Leitch

Doreen Lafferty

Taylor St. Pierre

Jacob Lafferty

Wil Thompson

Rodney Nichols

Ty Loupelle

Young Joseph Smith

Christopher Heyerdahl

Ammon Lafferty

Sandra Seacat

Josie Pyre

Darren Goldstein

Mr. Wright

Andrew Burnap

Joseph Smith

Tyner Rushing

Emma Smith

Michelle Wienecke

Lynn Lafferty

Rohan Mead

Morris

Britt Irvin

Sarah Lafferty

Christopher Heatherington

Motel Manager

Robert Corness

Elderly Brother Alder

Scott Olynek

Officer Denney

Joel Stephanson

Officer Halliday

Jerod Blake

Desk Cop

Alba Evora Weiler

Caroline Pyre

Olivia Collier

Brenda's Sister 1

Madeleine Murphy-Northcott

Brenda's Sister 2

Sophia Fabris

Brenda's Sister 3

Samuel Skye Kinaschuk Zeffer

Brenda's Brother

Carina Battrick

Sam's Jenny Lafferty

Beau McHattie

Ron Lafferty Boy 2

Emily James

Ron Lafferty Girl 1

Ariane Thomson

Matilda's Cora

Abelynne Langille

Matilda's Eilidh

Sarah Desjardins

Young Emma Smith

Rick Koy

Major Carlton

Scott Michael Campbell

Brigham Young

Vanessa Holmes

Laura Wright

Marty Antonini

Forest Ranger

Blair Young

Professor

Tim Perez

Suited Man

Gillian Barber

Sister Dorren

Lori Bachynski

Brenda's Neighbor

Patrick Keating

Old Man Patient

Alayna Edwards

Sam's Girl 2

David Haysom

Ohioan

Luke Lambert

Desperate LDS Boy

Duval Lang

Ohio Doctor

Declan O'Reilly

Ohio Town Official

Paul Wood

Thin Man

Sienna King

Annie Pyre

Tiffany Helm

Brigham's Wife #2

Sebastian Greaves

Missionary

Fionn Laird

Missionary

Lorette Clow

Mrs. Stowe

Shane Ghostkeeper

Convenience Store Clerk

Sarah Haggeman

Bryant Wife

Julia Van Dam

Bryant Wife

Megan Reneau

Bryant Wife