Tom Mison

Ichabod Crane

Janina Gavankar

Diana Thomas

Nicole Beharie

Abbie Mills

Lyndie Greenwood

Jenny Mills

Jerry MacKinnon

Jake Wells

Rachel Melvin

Alex Norwood

Nikki Reed

Betsy Ross

Zach Appelman

Joe Corbin

Oona Yaffe

Molly Thomas

Lance Gross

Daniel Reynolds

Shannyn Sossamon

Pandora

Orlando Jones

Frank Irving

John Noble

Henry Parrish

Jeremy Davies

Malcolm Dreyfuss

Heather V. Regnier

Karaoke Announcer

John Cho

Andy Brooks

Nestor Serrano

Polygraph Technician

Nicholas Gonzalez

Detective Luke Morales

Charles Malik Whitfield

Parsons

James Frain

Rutledge

Katia Winter

Katrina Crane

Tongayi Chirisa

Arthur Bernard

Craig Parker

Colonel Tarleton

Erin Cahill

Lena Gilbert

Laura Spencer

Caroline

Steven Weber

Thomas Jefferson

Emily Deschanel

Dr. Temperance Brennan

David Boreanaz

FBI Special Agent Seeley Booth

Johnathon Schaech

Reverend Solomon Kent

Chris Bert

Nelson Meyers

Sharif Atkins

Calvin Riggs

Carsten Nørgaard

Hessian

Alex Collins

Thomasson

Tim Holt

Redcoat

Jackson Beals

Mason Guard

Parker Chapin

Crying Boy

Michelle Trachtenberg

Abigail Adams

Matt Barr

Nick Hawley

Jaime Murray

Carmilla Pines

Jill Marie Jones

Cynthia Irving

Ashley LeConte Campbell

Judge Aldrin

Genevive Barker

Newscaster

Chris Greene

Daniel Riggs

Fernando Martinez

Burke

Jeremy Palko

McGrady

Richard Fullerton

Veteran

Jessi Goei

Young Teen #1

Alyssa Nicole Claytor

Young Teen #2

Adam Boyer

Bowie

Al-Jaleel Knox

Clerk - Tony

Marc Menchaca

Colonel Sutton

RJ Shearer

Private McMillan

Alan Heckner

Jailer

Matt Dearman

Soldier

Matt Medrano

Wistaron

Michael Teh

Seamus Duncan

Avis-Marie Barnes

Night Shift Nurse

Angela Bond

Paige Gillespie

Pete Burris

Garrett Gillespie

Amandla Stenberg

Macey Irving

David Fonteno

Reverend Boland

Kathleen York

Ms. Hudson

Nydia McFadden

Possessed Macey

Brennan Brown

Tom - Detective

Louis Herthum

General George Washington

Patrick Gorman

Reverend Alfred Knapp

Victor Garber

Mr. Crane

Francie Swift

Beth Lancaster

Heather Lind

Mary Wells

Eddie Spears

Big Ash

Adam Sinclair

Hellfire Club Doctor

Caroline Ford

Lilith

Cynthia Stevenson

Nurse Gina Lambert

Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor

Lori Mills

Max Brown

Orion

Aaron Serotsky

Grant Hollister

Surely Alvelo

Terrytown Psych Nurse

Stephen Michael Ayers

Shopkeeper

Scott DePoy

Priest

Kimberley Drummond

Sofie

Marc Farley

Gerry

Aaron K Smalls

Staffer

Adora Dei

CDC Member

Adrienne Whitney Papp

Assistant

Alan Boell

Sleepy Hollow Officer

Alan Wells

Intermediary

Alana Cavanaugh

Saffron Paynter

Alex Sgambati

Dani

Alexander Ward

The Ghoul

Allie McCulloch

Farmer

Alphie Hyorth

Judge

Andrea Powell

Mary Rawlings

Andy Pessoa

Young Ichabod

Andy Stahl

Donaldson (uncredited)

Antwan Mills

Guard

Barrett Carnahan

Sherman

Benjamin Keepers

Brent

Bethany Levy

The Soucouyant

Bill Heck

Mitch Talbot

Bill Irwin

Atticus Nevins

Bjorn Dupaty

Ansel

Brad Ashten

Francis Scott Key

Braden Fitzgerald

Young Jeremy Crane

C. Thomas Howell

SAC Mick Granger

Catherine Copplestone

PTA President

Catherine Dyer

Nancy Stryker

Cedric Greenway

Marine Guard

Charlene Amoia

Susan James

Charles Aitken

Dr. Japeth Leeds / The Jersey Devil

Charles Justo

Brad

Charmin Lee

Madam President

Chris Gann

Van Driver

Christopher Coakley

Samuel Nelson

Claire Bronson

Denise Hemmington

Clancy Brown

Sheriff August Corbin

Craig Branham

Headless Horseman (Horseback)

Craig Stark

Chase Weaver

Cullen Moss

ICE Officer

Dane Rhodes

Jeff

Daniel Thomas May

James Colby

Daryn Kahn

Souvenir Seller

Dave MacDonald

Plunkett

Dave Maldonado

Derek (Fireman)

Deborah Ayorinde

Michelle

Déjá Dee

Desk Clerk

Derek Mears

Golem

Diesel Madkins

Restoration Driver

Drew Matthews

Young Nevins

Dustin Lewis

Paul Revere

Dwayne Boyd

Sleepy Hollow Officer #2

Edwin Hodge

Benjamin Banneker

Erica Page

Chat Lady

Garrett Kruithof

Colonial Soldier

Gregory Nassif St. John

Evan Miller

Griff Furst

Mr. Branson

Hayley Lovitt

Bryce

James Chen

Lorenzo Chang

James Kyson

SAC Mark Wong

James McDaniel

Ezra Mills

Jared Simon

Polygraph Examiner

Jason Davis

Jeremy Furth

Jason Looney

Robbie Malone

Jason Stuart

Curator

Jayson Warner Smith

Carlton

Jeff Sprauve

Cop

Jesse C. Boyd

Aaron

Jessica Camacho

Agent Sophie Foster

Jimmy Gonzales

Homicide Detective Nuñez

Joe Heath

Hessian Soldier (uncredited)

Joe Knezevich

Father Daniel

John Curran

Oxford Professor

John Michael Weatherly

Secret Service

John Zachary

Abraham Lincoln

Jon Kohler

Sammy

Jonathan D. Williams

Rob

Jose Miguel Vasquez

Agent Ramirez

Josh Ventura

Matt Gorman

Joshua Hoover

Host

Joy Glover Walters

Medic

Joy Jacobson

Ms. Galway

Judd Lormand

Vendor

Julia Armitage

Alice

Julia Vasi

Rosa

Kamar de los Reyes

Jobe

Karen Beyer

Woman

Kelley Missal

Malligo Dyer

Kendrick Cross

Crane's Lawyer

Kenneth Israel

Police Officer

Kevin Patrick Murphy

Ananias Dare

Lawrence Kao

Donnie Lu

Lily D. Moore

Teammate #3

Lindsay Ayliffe

Stephens

Lindsey Garrett

Sarah Osborne

Lynne Ashe

Brenda (Bailiff)

Marco Schittone

David

Mark Ashworth

Connor Dunne

Mark Jeffrey Miller

Jesse Adams

Marti Matulis

Scarecrow

Mary Kraft

Dr. Vega

Matt Lewis

Drummer

Matt Lintz

Thomas Grey

Matthew Luret

Marquis de Lafayette

Maya Kazan

Zoe Corinth

Megan Hayes

Dana Dobbs

Michael Harding

Gil Everett

Michael O'Keefe

Director Jack Walters

Michael Roark

Devon Jones

Michael Shenefelt

Doug

Michael Sokol

Bald Zombie

Michael Tourek

Prison Guard

Michelle Rivera Huckaby

EMT

Mike Whaley

Police Officer

Miles Doleac

William Grey

Monique Ganderton

Serilda

Morgan Ayres

Young Corbin

Morgan Brown

Church Member #3

Myke Holmes

Walt

Neil Jackson

Abraham Van Brunt

Neko Parham

Fuller

Nelson Bonilla

Vincent

Nick Madrick

Unit Leader

Nick Stanner

Ripper

Nolan Bateman

Ronnie Rawlings

Onye Eme-Akwari

Classy Guy

Paul Brian Johnson

Forensic Tech

Peter Mensah

The Hidden One

Phillip DeVona

Wendel Clark

Quinten Johnson

Young Butler

R. Keith Harris

Landlord

Randy Havens

Patrick McKenna

Reginald Lashaun Clay

Booking Sheriff

Rey Hernandez

Military Patrolman

Richard Cetrone

Headless Horseman (Weapons)

Rick Espaillat

Samuel Wilson

Robbie Kay

Logan MacDonald

Ron Roggé

Henry Knox / Theodore Knox

Rotimi Paul

Azzaca

Roy McCrerey

Hans Christensen

Ryan Boz

Lancaster-Weiss Brother #1

Sakina Jaffrey

Sheriff Leena Reyes

Samuel Smith

Motorcycle Escort Driver

Sasha Morfaw

Classy Girl

Scott Poythress

Benedict Arnold

Selena Anduze

Manager

Seychelle Gabriel

Lara

Shane Callahan

Wagon Guard

Shay Mack

Church Woman Who Screams

Sir Brodie

Priest

Sophia Grillo

Bachelorette

Stephen Ruffin

Teen Dracula

Tara Lee

Soccer Mom

Terrence Mann

The Devil

Timothy Busfield

Benjamin Franklin

Tom Hillmann

Richard Weiss

Tyler Chase

Teenage Clerk

Tyshon Freeman

Bruiser Frat Guy

Victor Cordova

Officer #1

Victor Turner

Blake

Vince Pisani

Paul Short

Yan Feldman

Ben

Zae Jordan

Paul Jennings