Hamish Linklater

Father Paul Hill

Zach Gilford

Riley Flynn

Kate Siegel

Erin Greene

Samantha Sloyan

Bev Keane

Rahul Kohli

Sheriff Hassan

Henry Thomas

Ed Flynn

Kristin Lehman

Annie Flynn

Igby Rigney

Warren Flynn

Annarah Cymone

Leeza Scarborough

Annabeth Gish

Dr. Sarah Gunning

Alex Essoe

Mildred Gunning

Matt Biedel

Sturge

Michael Trucco

Wade Scarborough

Crystal Balint

Dolly Scarborough

Rahul Abburi

Ali Hassan

Louis Oliver

Ooker

Mike Flanagan

Young Priest

Andrew Grush

Organist

Carla Gugino

Judge

Robert Longstreet

Joe Collie

Quinton Boisclair

Angel

John C. MacDonald

Bowl

Anup Sehdev

Paramedic

Lyza Ulrych

Victim's Mother

Kapila Rego

Lawyer

Michael Tiernan

Mailman

Patricia Drake

Joanie

Vincent Gale

Howie Hobbs

Tanis Dolman

Hysterical Woman

Pasha Ebrahimi

Parishioner #1

Ese Atawo

Parishioner #2

Marci T. House

Mainland Doctor

Jaren Moore

AA Moderator

Camille Atebe

Attractive Woman

Kendall Goddard

Mother to young children (uncredited)

Bobby Leigh

Hank (uncredited)

Ebony Booth

Tara-Beth