Janet Montgomery

Mary Sibley

Shane West

John Alden

Seth Gabel

Cotton Mather

Tamzin Merchant

Anne Hale

Ashley Madekwe

Tituba

Elise Eberle

Mercy Lewis

Xander Berkeley

Magistrat Hale

Iddo Goldberg

Isaac Walton

Oliver Bell

Little John

Lucy Lawless

Condessa Marburg

Joe Doyle

Baron Sebastian Marburg

Lucy Faust

Elizabeth

Stephen Lang

Increase Mather

Antonia Prebble

Bridget Bishop

Hank Harris

Corwin

Clint James

Isaac's Man

Braden Fitzgerald

Stephen

Ashton Smiley

Acolyte

Samuel Roukin

The Sentinel

Nadine Lewington

Rebecca Nurse

Lara Grice

Mrs. Hale

Caroline Hebert

Teenage Girl

David Shiflett

Naked Dead Body

Ava Ticotin

Past Countess

Emily Skeggs

Billy

Kevin Tighe

Giles Corey