Melissa Joan Hart

Sabrina Spellman

Caroline Rhea

Hilda Spellman

Elisa Donovan

Morgan Cavanaugh

Beth Broderick

Zelda Spellman

Nate Richert

Harvey Kinkle

Soleil Moon Frye

Roxie King

Jenna Leigh Green

Libby Chessler

Martin Mull

Willard Kraft

Michelle Beaudoin

Jenny Kelley

Paul Feig

Eugene Poole

Lindsay Sloane

Valerie Birkhead

Alimi Ballard

Quizmaster

Nick Bakay

Salem Saberhagen (voice)

Robby Benson

Edward Spellman

Frank Conniff

Prince Randy

Jesse Plemons

Bigger Kid

Sean Cw Johnson

Delivery Man

Louisa Abernathy

Caterer

Teller

Skippy

Debbie Harry

Cassandra

Penn Jillette

Drell

Bridget Flanery

Jill

Shaun Weiss

Male Student

Ella Joyce

Mrs. Bogzigian

Eddie Allen

Guidance Counselor

Tom McGowan

Principal Larue

Randy Travis

Ideal Man

Beth Kennedy

Carol

Jim Hanks

Jerry

Diana Theodore

Girl #1

Sara Van Horn

Marge

Milo Ventimiglia

Letterman

Phillip Glasser

Student #2

Aeryk Egan

Sports Announcer

Eddie Cibrian

Darryl

Sally Jessy Raphael

Sally Jessy Raphael

Diane McBain

Granny

Robin Riker

Marigold

Jay Kogen

Mr. Altree

Thomas F. Wilson

Simon

Nicole Bilderback

Sasha

Darin Singleton

Raphael

Curtis Andersen

Gordie

Raquel Welch

Vesta

Braeden Marcott

Cletus

Andrew Keegan

Magic Joel

Emily Hart

Young Sabrina (uncredited)

Paul Provenza

Ethan

Mark Fite

Cicero

John Knight

Matt Sabetti

Cary-Hiroyuki Tagawa

Tai Wai Tse

Vien Hong

Trophy

Coolio

Coolio

Dana Gould

Monty

Seth Adkins

Rex

Joe O'Connor

Joe

Kerry Norton

Lulu

Kathy Ireland

Shelley

Ed Begley Jr.

Mr. Rothwell

Linda Kash

M'Lady (voice)

Steve Bannos

Judge #1

Jack Wagner

Jack Wagner

Chuck McCann

Repairman

Morwenna Banks

Rules Bearer

Brady Anderson

Brady Anderson

Judith Jones

Zellary

Alexandra Johnes

Hillary

Gordon Gano

Gordon Gano

Brian Ritchie

Brian Ritchie

Bubba Smith

Security Guard

Richard Tanner

Door Guy

Chris Elliott

Warren

David Chokachi

Doug

Sondra Spriggs

Mrs. Hecht

Paul Michael Robinson

Zak

Peter Marshall

Game Show Host

Karen Morrow

Nana

Alan Young

Mr. Berry

Angelo Vacco

Delivery Guy

Beth Howland

Mrs. Ericson

Aaron Carter

Aaron Carter

AJ McLean

A.J. McLean - Backstreet Boys

Alan Sues

Bellevuedere

Alex Rocco

Sid Wolff

Allen Williams

Professor Klaveman

Andrew W. Walker

Cole Harper

Aria Noelle Curzon

Young Hilda

Arturo Gil

Male Elf

Ashanti

Ashanti

Beth Grant

Mrs. Popowski

Betty Okino

Mary

Billy West

Newt (voice)

Brian Austin Green

Chad

Brian Patrick Wade

Kim

Bryan Cranston

Witch Lawyer

Bumper Robinson

Clifford

Carol Ann Susi

Doris

Cee Cee Michaela

Cee Cee

Charles Shaughnessy

Alec

Charles Walker

Coach

Christina Vidal Mitchell

Fate Paris

Christopher Emerson

Adam

Christopher Michael

Bailiff

Christopher Rich

John

Clement von Franckenstein

Rodin

Conchata Ferrell

Bus Driver

Cork Hubbert

Fritz

Cory Buck

Boy Prince

Cristine Rose

Mrs. Chessler

D. Elliot Woods

Professor

Da Brat

Baby K2K

Dana Woods

Pressburger

Daniel Bedingfield

Daniel Bedingfield

Dave Allen

Pizza Manager

David L. Lander

Postmaster

David Lascher

Josh

Davy Jones

Davy Jones

Debbe Dunning

Veronique

Dennis Fimple

Farmer

Dick Clark

Dick Clark

Dick Van Dyke

Duke

Don Most

White Rabbit

Dona Hardy

May

Donald Faison

Justin

Donna Pieroni

Euterpe

Douglas Sills

Steward

Drew Carey

Drew Carey

Dylan Cash

Billy Johnson

Dylan Neal

Aaron Jacobs

E.J. Callahan

Clerk #3

Ed Gale

Powell

Ed McMahon

Ed McMahon

Edward Albert

Diamond Dave

Elayn J. Taylor

Casting Director

Ellen Albertini Dow

Old Lady

Fred Stoller

C.K.

Garry Marshall

Mickey Brentwood

Gary Grubbs

Boyd

Gary Owens

Guy Who Thinks He's Gary Owens

Gary Sandy

Wally

Geoff Pierson

Wayne Banning

Greg Lewis

Don Tutti Frutti

Harrison Young

Vagrant

Harry S. Murphy

Guidance Counselor

Hope Levy

Contest Winner

Ian Lyons

Waiter

Irene Olga López

Mrs. Martinez

Isaac C. Singleton, Jr.

Bouncer

J.G. Hertzler

Plato

J.P. Manoux

Counter Guy

James Michael Tyler

Ethan

James Read

Ben

Jane Carr

Dr. Bull

Jason James Richter

Dante

JC Chasez

JC Chasez

Jenna Stewart

Woman

Jere Burns

Gabriel

Jim Hanna

Reporter

Jim Wise

Brady

Jo Anne Worley

Aunt Beulah

Joan Marie Laurer

Mary Jo Ponder

Joe Howard

Minister

Joe Ochman

Shop Owner

Joel David Moore

Pete

Joey Nader

Desk Clerk

John Ducey

Dwayne Kraft

John Griffin

Freedom Fighter

John Harnagel

Guest

John Patrick White

Adam

Jorge-Luis Pallo

Student

Joseph G. Medalis

Justice of the Peace

Josh Blake

Pete

Judy Kain

Doris

Justin Jon Ross

Warren

Kal Penn

Prajeeb

Kasan Butcher

Bob

Kate Jackson

Candy

Kay E. Kuter

Father Christmas

Keri Lynn Pratt

Lynn

Kevin Moon

TV Announcer (voice)

Kevin Nash

Giant

Lance Bass

Lance Bass

Larry Dorf

George

Len Lesser

Eugene

Linda Kim

Clio

Lisa Darr

Martha

Lisa K. Wyatt

Ruby

Lori Alan

Sabrina's Car (voice)

Louan Gideon

Eleanor

Mak Takano

Sushi Chef #1

Manu Intiraymi

Sore Throat

Marcy Goldman

Customer #3

Mari Weiss

Customer #1

Mark Chaet

Professor Dillard

Mark L. Taylor

Professor Hopkins

Mary Bogue

French Hen

Mary Gillis

Witch Judge

Mary Gross

Mrs. Quick

Mary Hart

Mary Hart

Masi Oka

Male Council Member

Matt McCoy

Calvin

Matt Winston

Bob

Michael Caldwell

Caterer

Michael Trucco

Kevin

Mike Grief

Michaelangelo

Ming Lo

Foreign Man

Monty Hall

Monty Hall

Monty Sopp

Xavier Prescott

Nicole Scherzinger

Pop Star #3

P.J. Marino

Tom

Parry Shen

Seth

Patrick Thomas O'Brien

Index Man

Patty Toy

Daphne

Paul Blake

Billy

Paul Keith

Minister

Paul Rae

Worker

Paul Sand

Dr. Rafkin

Paul Taylor

Security Guard

Peggy Miley

Mrs. Smiley

Peter Scolari

Ringmaster

Phil Nee

Mr. Willoughby

Raffi Di Blasio

Alan

Ren Woods

Mrs. Hecht

Richard Steven Horvitz

Smaller Chair (voice)

Robert Dorfman

Gustav

Robert Noble

City Inspector

Roger Eschbacher

Steve

Ron Fassler

Agent

Ron Lester

Wally

Roz Witt

Woman

Ruth Buzzi

Delilah

Sally Struthers

Aunt Lorraine

Sandra McCoy

Attractive Woman

Sean Moran

Mailman

Sean Smith

Ken

Sheryl Lee Ralph

Zsa Zsa Goowhiggie

Steven Anthony Lawrence

Little Kid

Steven M. Porter

Bryce

Stu Nahan

TV Announcer

Tami Roman

Saleslady #1

Ted Kairys

Justin

Teddy Lane Jr.

Police Officer

Teri Garr

Yenta

Tim Bagley

Mr. Cornwallis

Tim Thomerson

Mr. Alcerro

Tisha Campbell

Joyce

Tom Beyer

Staff Member #2

Tom Fahn

Pedestrian

Tom Magliozzi

Click

Tom Poston

Mortgage Banker

Tom Virtue

Mr. Cavanaugh

Valarie Pettiford

Calliope

Victor Raider-Wexler

Judge

Vitamin C

Cathy Winters

Wendy Worthington

Mrs. Poupiepenz

William Dennis Hunt

Boris Lermontov

Winston Story

Joe

Zac Hanson

Zac Hanson