Ella Beatty

Lizzie Borden

Vicky Krieps

Bridget Sullivan

Sarah Paulson

Aileen Wuornos

Charlie Hunnam

Andrew Borden

Rebecca Hall

Abby Borden

Billie Lourd

Emma Borden

Jessica Barden

Nance O’Neil

A.J. Tannen

Judge Thomas Saway

Aaron Hendry

Oberon

Aimee McGuire

Margaret

Alan Heitz

Detective John Devine

Ari Graynor

Michelle Gillen

Bernadette Guckin

Carolyn

Brian Knoebel

Son

Brian Tichnell

Playgoer

Chad Coe

Deputy Francis Wixon

Chris O'Shea

Heath Westcott

Daniel Abraham Stevens

Bailiff

David St. James

Doctor

Doug Cox

Juror #4

Elise Krieps

Young Elizabetta

Elizabeth Scopel

Callie

Ember Ambrose

8-Year-Old Emma

Ezra Buzzington

Detective Michael Mullaly

Flavia Leone

Middle Daughter

Fred Maske

Postmaster

Gabriel Sousa

Tiago

Gabrielle Sanalitro

Lead Juror

Greg Barnett

AP William Moody

Herbert Russell

Coroner

Hugo Armstrong

Harlan

Jack Lancaster

Brother Borden

Jacopo Olmo Antinori

Western Union Man

Jay Alan Christianson

Jury Foreman

Jeanine Anderson

Neighbor

Jim Cody Williams

Fishmonger

Joanna Leeds

Tricia Jenkins

Joey Pollari

John Morse

John Ales

Hosea Knowlton

John Venable

Monsignor

Jordan Hendricks

Assistant District Attorney

Joseph Schwartz

Officer George Allen

Joshua Close

Officer Patrick Doherty

Lauri Hendler

Mrs. Enid Wheatley

Lidia Vitale

Servant

Linda Reiter

Bertha Manchester

Luca Pusceddu

Partygoer

Madylin Sweeten

Trixie

Matthew Siegan

Reporter

Michael McCusker

Bard Wainwright

Michael O'Connell

Defense Attorney

Michael Sean Tighe

Pharmacist

Michael X. Sommers

Juror #8

Samuel Dunning

Policeman

Scarlett DeMeo

Sarah Anthony Borden

Steven Lee Allen

Juror #6

Stewart Skelton

Minister

Therese McLaughlin

Widow

Tom Fitzpatrick

Judge

Tom Virtue

Doctor

Trilby Glover

Thandie Wilcox

Troy Blendell

Coroner

Zachary Mooren

Atelier