Alicia Silverstone

Kate Fox

Lake Bell

Victoria Carlson

David Conrad

Michael Mendelson

Jodi Long

Claire

James Roday Rodriguez

Nick Paine

Ryan O'Neal

Jerry Fox

Melissa Errico

Laurel

Amanda Detmer

Gabrielle Davis

Wallace Langham

Lucas

Angela Goethals

Jessica

Rachel Shelley

Rebecca Hanley

Diane Mizota

The Bride

Deanna Wright

Paulette

Eddie McClintock

Colin

Michaela Watkins

Susan Scott

Edita Brychta

Barbara Stone

Brian Dunkleman

TV Host

Ajay Mehta

Mr. Chopra

Michele Lee

Sandy

Christina Hendricks

Sarah

Heather Hopper

Coffee House Cashier

Nathan Fillion

Adam Logan

Galen Gering

Adrian

Teresa Strasser

Self

Jenna Fischer

Connie

Eyal Podell

Glenn Cooper

Kurt Long

Sam

Maria Thayer

Chelsea Greer

Diana Maria Riva

Rhea Stern

Dan Butler

Chuck Webb

Kaitlin Olson

Jillian

Kevin Kilner

Dr. John

Marita Geraghty

Meaghan Smalls

María Canals Barrera

Store Manager

Maria Canals-Barrera

Caroline Aaron

Judy Schiff

Romany Malco

Master Z

Chris Johnson

Daniel

Brad Rowe

Dave Hillman

Skyler Gisondo

Jeffrey

Dina Meyer

Lauren Logan

Dan Gilvezan

Lou Davis

Nicole Randall Johnson

Nicole

Eddie Kaye Thomas

Scott

Leonard L. Thomas

Bailiff

Danielle Bisutti

Missy

Alastair Duncan

Ian

Adam Goldberg

Jarred

Jonathan Silverman

Barry

Hailey Noelle Johnson

Little Girl

Barry Pearl

Morty

Jeannie Berlin

Risa Barbeko

Faith Salie

Martha Elkin

Bradley Cooper

Gary Wagner

Johann Urb

Dave

Richard Kind

Phil Weston

Charisma Carpenter

Serena Lockner

Jill Ritchie

Haley

Nicole Sullivan

Rachel

Lindsay Sloane

Daphne

Kate Orsini

Bridget

Brian Baker

Bob Elkin

David Alan Basche

Brian

Amanda Foreman

Marla Kenton

Jan Devereaux

Ellen's Attorney

Marcus Lyle Brown

Acteur

Debra Christofferson

Judge Blake

Katherine LaNasa

Amy Jensen

Ion Overman

Michelle's first date

Kim Fields

Sherri

Chad Cox

Guest

William Ragsdale

Russell Dixon

Anna Gunn

Maureen Weston

Johnny Sneed

Dean Delane

Daniel Dae Kim

Clifford Kim

Sunita Param

Rashmi

Kerr Smith

Santa Claus

Salli Saffioti

Debra Maynor, Karl's attorney

Paula Marshall

Kathryn Hammond

Saba Homayoon

Secretary

Ben Weber

Craig Baxter

Laurel Green

Julia Baxter