Jonathan Groff

Patrick Murray

Frankie J. Alvarez

Agustín Lanuez

Murray Bartlett

Dom Basaluzzo

Russell Tovey

Kevin Matheson

Lauren Weedman

Doris

Raúl Castillo

Ricardo "Richie" Donado Ventura

Scott Bakula

Lynn

Tanya Saracho

Ceci

Jhoni Marchinko

Noelle

O-T Fagbenle

Frank

Tanner Cohen

Scotty

Ann Magnuson

Stina

Matthew Wilkas

Benjamin

Derek Ray

Ethan

Andrew Keenan-Bolger

Alex

TJ Linnard

CJ

Ptolemy Slocum

Hugo

Joe Williamson

Jon

Carlos Carrasco

Jack

Richard Conti

Randy

Kimberly Legg

Bethany

Kelli Garner

Megan Murray

Julia Duffy

Dana Murray

Matthew Risch

Matthew

Daniel Franzese

Eddie

Brian Gattas

Faerie

Adrian Anchondo

Adrian

Bashir Salahuddin

Malik

Chris Perfetti

Brady

Jesse Garcia

Hector

Mary Kay Place

Aunt Sarah

Hayes MacArthur

Barry Foster

John Robinson

Liam

Boston Rush Freeman

Zoo Visitor (uncredited)

Honey Mahogany

Self

Andrew Law

Owen

Jason Ralph

Jason

Scott Evans

Cody Heller

Anthony Hill

Robert

Jennifer Foster

Kyah

Amy York Rubin

Meredith

Lo Mutuc

Cashier

Gabe Liedman

Brent

Christine Estabrook

Realtor

Wesley Taylor

Milo

Sean Maher

Jake

Iván Jesús Herrera

Gutter Punk Kid

D'Lo

Taj