Aubrey Plaza

Laura Feinberg (voice)

Lucy DeVito

Chrissy Feinberg (voice)

Danny DeVito

Satan (voice)

Michael Shannon

Unshaven Man (voice)

D.J. 'Shangela' Pierce

Queen Inichoochiama (voice)

Arnold Schwarzenegger

Game Show Host (voice)

Laci Mosley

Librarian / Townsperson (voice)

Eugene Cordero

Bennigan (voice)