Kiernan Shipka

Sabrina Spellman

Ross Lynch

Harvey Kinkle

Lucy Davis

Hilda Spellman

Miranda Otto

Zelda Spellman

Chance Perdomo

Ambrose Spellman

Michelle Gomez

Mary Wardwell

Jaz Sinclair

Rosalind Walker

Richard Coyle

Father Blackwood

Tati Gabrielle

Prudence Night

Adeline Rudolph

Agatha

Gavin Leatherwood

Nick Scratch

Darren Mann

Luke Chalfant

Lachlan Watson

Susie Putnam

Kurt Max Runte

Mr. Kemper

John Rubinstein

Daniel Webster

Vanessa Przada

Webster's Daughter

Cassandra Naud

Dancer (uncredited)

Quinton Boisclair

Amalia

Aaron Hale

Seth Grinwis

BJ Harrison

Mrs. Curtis

Kavandeep Hayre

Ed Dursley

Richard Ian Cox

Trivium #1 (Judge)

Jett Klyne

Young Harvey

Nicole G. Leier

History Teacher

Christiaan Westerveld

Infernal Bailiff

Liam Hughes

Quentin

Megan Leitch

Batibat

Jack Sandison

Fergus

Linden Banks

Dr. Carpenter

Jason Beaudoin

Uncle Jesse

Lissa Neptuno

Dr. Spector

Michael Hogan

Granpa Kinkle

Alvina August

Lady Constance Blackwood

Brenda McDonald

Dezmelda

Sarah-Jane Redmond

Mrs. Kemper

Kimi Alexander

Female Coven Choir #2

Carmel Amit

Mildred

Maria Epih

Witch #2

Eunice Kang

Female Coven Choir #4

Cynthia Mendez

Female Coven Choir #3

Moses Thiessen

Ben Button

Arielle Tuliao

Female Coven Choir #1

Anita Wittenberg

Witch #1

Beth Broderick

Zelda Spellman

Caroline Rhea

Hilda Spellman

Chris Walters

Matt

Luke Cook

Lucifer Morningstar

Meaghan Chenosky

Donna

Sam Corlett

Caliban

Jonathan Whitesell

Robin Goodfellow

James Urbaniak

The Trinket Man

Tyler Cotton

Melvin

Xantha Radley

Mrs. Meeks

Whitney Peak

Judith

Melody Nosipho Niemann

Trick-or-Treat Witch

Billy Christos Jr.

Trick-or-Treat Kid #2

Connor O'Mahony

Trick-or-Treat Kid #3

Reese Alexander

Thomas Walker

Guy Christie

Mr. Morris

Aadila Dosani

Doctor

Justin Dobies

Tommy Kinkle

Em Haine

Em Haine

Panthea Vatandoost

Screaming Student

Charmaine Wilson

Crone

Bronson Pinchot

Principal George Hawthorne

Alessandro Juliani

Dr. Cee

L. Scott Caldwell

Nana Ruth

Anastasia Bandey

Dorothea

Christina Church

Greendale Thirteen #5

Jenna Berman

Young Woman

Kendall Goddard

Greendale Thirteen #1

Elizabeth Iversen

Greendale Thirteen #3

Melissa M. Montgomery

Greendale Thirteen #4

Rachel Renaud

Meek Teenage Girl

Jacqueline Robbins

Head Witch

Madison Smith

Steve Loomis

Theresa Wong

Greendale Thirteen #2

Mckenna Grace

Young Sabrina Spellman

Brian Markinson

Sin Bartel

Heather Doerksen

Gryla

Abby Ross

Dezmelda

Abigail Cowen

Dorcas

Adam DiMarco

Dario

Adrian Hough

Farmer Putnam

Alex Diakun

Cassius

Alexis Denisof

Adam Marsters

Bayley Corman

Mehitable

Charlie Kerr

Judas Society Boy #3

Christopher Rosamond

Mr. Kinkle

Daniel Boileau

Barfly Buddy

Daniel Nemes

Pontius Pilate

Darius Willis

Judas

Donald Sales

Purson

Dylan Sloane

Judas Society Boy #1

Emilija Baranac

Audrey

Gary Jones

Trivium #2 (Jury)

Graeme McComb

Gideon

Jasmine Vega

Lizzie

Jedidiah Goodacre

Dorian Gray

Jeffrey Joseph

Coach Craven

John Murphy

Asmodeus

Liam Hall

Marcus Pierce

Liz Wallace

Hazel

Marisa Gold

Masquerade Dancer

Megan Serena Trainer

Dancer

Nathalie Boltt

Ms. Dubois

Navid Charkhi

Dancer

Nelson Leis

Beelzebub

Nicco Del Rio

Dave

Nikolai Witschl

Howard

Oliver Rice

Barabbas

Patrick Keating

Hobo

Peter Bundic

Carl Tapper

Pollyanna McIntosh

Metatron

Quinn Greysen

Peggy Lou Simcox

Ray Wise

Enoch

Rochelle Greenwood

Shirley Jackson

Ron Selmour

Baron Samedi

Ross Wirtanen

Dancer

Saskia Wedding

Salome

Spencer Lang

Strong Man #2

Spencer Treat Clark

Jerathmiel

Stephanie Lavigne

Dancer

Ty Wood

Billy Marlin

Veronica Cartwright

Fortune Teller

William B. Davis

Methuselah