Beth Karas

Self - Legal Expert

Natalia Grace Rene Mans

Self

Kristine Barnett

Self - Natalia's Adoptive Mother (archive footage)

Nicole DePaul

Self

Mackenzie DePaul

Self - Nicole's Daughter

Michael Barnett

Self - Natalia's Adoptive Father

Bob Goldsmith

Self - Sheriff, Tippecanoe County

Brandon Davenport

Self - Detective, Indiana State Police

Veronica Maxwell

Self - Ret. Special Agent, FBI

Kenneth J. Maxwell

Self - Ret. Asst. Special Agent in Charge, FBI

Eric Evangelista

Self - Executive Producer

Vince DePaul

Self - Nicole's Husband