Anthony D. Call

Self - Narrator

Grant Gustin

Thomas - Stacy's Boyfriend

Lia McHugh

Jacey

Pierce Pope

Colin

Arne Cheyenne Johnson

Self

Jason Alan Cook

Stephen

Chase Anderson

Tyler

A.J. Lister

Young Sabrina

Todd Brown

Steve Jasmine

Denise Hillis

Theresa

Shae Britt

Middle Daughter

Lorraine Warren

Self

Debora Balardini

Lee

Jim Meisner Jr.

Hospital Priest

Jacquie Walters

Jennifer

Amy Allan

Medium

Hans Holzer

Self - Paranormal Researcher

Beau Peregino

Carl Lawson

Bobby Mackey

Self

Douglas Hensley

Self - Writer

Johnny Alonso

Mike Esperanza

Bridget Gethins

Regina Mathews

Taylor Lyons

Mary Fox

August Armstrong

Wican Grandmother

Michael J. Patterson

Neighbor

Jay SanGiovanni

Wesley Fox

Brandon Carroll

Frank

Terry Menefee Gau

Psychic

Jessica Hutson

Patty Bean

Karen Carbone

Jan Foster

Tony Pickman

Self

Debra Pickman

Self

Peter James

Self - Paranormal Investigator

Todd Ryan Jones

Tony Pickman

Jayce O'Neal

Arne Johnson

Reshaun Jones

Demon

Debbie Glatzel

Self

Chris Winters

Michael

Barry Ellenberger

Dan

Terry Jernigan

Richard Tyson

Scott Graham

Edd Dunham

Nicholas X. Parsons

Tom Blasko

Steven LaChance

Self

Marc Gable

Dad

Nick Ventura

Bobby Mackey

Kendal Tuttle

Randy Ervin

Ricky Chaplain

Roy Ervin

Charles Wissinger

Mike Bosick

Mikayla Park

Nora

Brandon Cordon

Jeremy Spencer

Lynn McCune

Debi White

Brenda Van Dorn

Second Mormon Wife

Nanci Hernandez-Hall

Nancy

Irv Becker

Joseph

Seth Caskey

Tim

Diana Cherkas

Kamylah

Dawn Westbrook

Mary Vogel

Keith Michael Gregory

House Guest

Robert Neal Marshall

John Zaffis

Chris Van Cleave

Exorcist Priest

John Zaffis

Self - Paranormal Investigator

Brittany Martz

Becky Miller

Justin Dray

Matt Brody

Ken Arnold

Steve

Shaun Cameron Hall

Bobby Wilcott

Kristen Hudson

Addie Wilcott

Ralph Denton Sr.

Ed Warren

David Harscheid

Pastor

Fred Iacovo

Priest

Mark Joy

Priest

Jennifer L. Marshall

Shannon

Tamara Johnson

Marcy Wikoff

Kelley Davis

Amy

Kera O'Bryon

Ginger Hinshaw

Marcello Rollando

Raymond, Ginger's Father

Cheryl Scungio

Cindy Sarro

Mackenzie Jo Pardi

Brooke Sarro

Scott Rollins

Arnold Hinshaw

Scott Oakley

Dennis

Sherrie Provence

Melissa

Alyx Libby

Jessica

Brian K. Landis

Harvey

David B. Meadows

Peter

David Ditmore

Stephen

Eleanor Drew

Rebecca's Mother

Hays Wellford

Digger's Son

Hilary Pingle

Hilary

Ian Novick

Courtenay Clapperton

Julia Deane

Tammy

Kate Silk

Victoria

Marianna Alacchi

Deborah Utley

Robert Shepherd

Neighbor

Rocco Poveromo

Mario

Sonia Debreczeni

Ellen MacNeil

Suzie Haines

Angelina

Tim Perez-Ross

Emiliano

Vic Stagliano

Bob

Victoria Beltran

Sandra

Vince Eisenson

Martin