Ioan Gruffudd

Henry Morgan

Judd Hirsch

Abe

Alana de la Garza

Detective Jo Martinez

Lorraine Toussaint

Lt. Joanne Reece

Donnie Keshawarz

Detective Hanson

Joel David Moore

Lucas

Mackenzie Mauzy

Abigail Morgan

Raul Casso

Carter Pilson

Birkett Turton

Paul Gould

Katie Paxton

Emily Sontag

Gary Basaraba

Norman Sontag

Blair Brown

Fawn Mahoney Ames

Emily Kinney

Jennifer Schroeder

Auden Thornton

Sarah Clancy

Burn Gorman

Adam

Barbara Eve Harris

Lt. Marcia Roark

Shamika Cotton

Anita

Danny Deferrari

Jo's man

Olga Maliouk

Russian woman

Jack Koenig

Captain

Lee Tergesen

Hans Koehler

Lou Ferguson

Old african slave

James McCaffrey

Browning

Dave Quay

Paul

Lawrence Arancio

Alex Hulquist

Angela Christian

Miranda Browning

Rachael Emrich

Vicky

Lakisha May

Sophomore girl

Royce Johnson

Campus security

Mather Zickel

Dr. Frederick Gardner

Christina Bennett Lind

Sasha Savchenko

Eric William Morris

Dr. James Carter

Kathleen Chalfant

Gloria Carlyle

Jack Gilpin

Conrad Carlyle

Janie Brookshire

Young Gloria

Michael Oberholtzer

Lance Sharp

Sonya Harum

Sophia Carlyle

Timothy Britten Parker

Ray Berkowitz

Tom Titone

Arty Berkowitz

Erika Rolfsrud

Marta Rosko

Rufus Collins

Museum director

James Colby

Tommy Delgros

Cornelius Smith, Jr.

Fabian North

Julian Gamble

Landlord

Rosalind Chao

Frenchman

Paul Fitzgerald

Mark

Andy Murray

Abberline

Mick Hazen

Devin Bentley

Hilarie Burton Morgan

Iona Payne

Robert Petkoff

Cliff Wadlow

Victoria Haynes

Nora Morgan

Jane Seymour

Maureen Delacroix

Christina Brucato

Gwyneth Gaines

Jason Babinsky

Richard Gaines

Joel Leffert

Psychiatrist

Jimmy Palumbo

Jon Worley

Brian Berrebbi

Studio tech

Eddie Cooper

Bud Gray

Frankie Faison

Pepper Evans

Tia Dionne Hodge

Ella Williams

Tarik Lowe

Isaiah 'Izzy' Williams

Laura Fraser

Patricia Abbott

James McDaniel

Al Rainey

Edoardo Ballerini

Clark Walker

Geoffrey Cantor

Alienist

Arash Mokhtar

Raj Patel

Mike Massimino

Bellevue guard

Emmanuel Brown

Cop #1

Lawrence Ballard

Detective

Ryan Quinlan

Cop #2

Clarke Peters

Jerry Charters

Sepideh Moafi

Melanie Sparo

Daniel Abeles

Val Kaplan

William Baldwin

Oliver Clarion

Michael Godere

Kevin Crachiolla

Steven Kaplan

Teen Abe

Anne Horak

Hannah Dalford

Shane McRae

Detective Hugh Dunn

Andy Karl

Sean Moore

Roger Rees

Priest

Angel Desai

Diane Clark

Betsey Brown

Lucy Templeton

Caleb McLaughlin

Alejandro

Frank Anello

Detective (uncredited)

Jacob Goodhart

Tattooed kid

Jery Hewitt

Bill Sayle

Jessica Keenan Wynn

Dina

Liz Logan

Detective (uncredited)

Meryl Jones Williams

Cassandra Mueller

Michael Crane

Forensic Tech

Nicky Torchia

Boy

Tom Alan Robbins

Phil Fleishman

Tyler Elliot Burke

Aaron Brown

Valeri Mudek

Belinda

Victor Joel Ortiz

Liam