Rebecca Romijn

Eve Baird

Christian Kane

Jake Stone

John Harlan Kim

Ezekiel Jones

Lindy Booth

Cassandra Cillian

John Larroquette

Jenkins

Noah Wyle

Flynn Carsen

Lesley-Ann Brandt

Lamia

Bruce Campbell

Santa

Michelle N. Carter

Dr. Ann Mills

Joanne Spracklen

Bo Peep

Lea Zawada

Katie Bender

Robert Wu

Sterling Lam

Ernie Reyes Jr.

Monkey King

Gia Carides

Lenore Jones

Steven Weber

Saint of Thieves

Gloria Reuben

Jade Wells

Margaret Avery

Eleanor Darnell

Eric Allan Kramer

Olafsson

Samuel Roukin

Darrington Dare

Howard Charles

Ambrose Gethic

T.J. Ramini

Robbie Bender

Katie Michels

Sally

Dilshad Vadsaria

Sarina

Nora Dunn

Janet Hedge

Andrew Lewis Caldwell

Jeff

Britney Young

Aurora

Rhyan Schwartz

Schmidt

Joseph Bertót

Dennis

Jeanine Jackson

Dolores Peppers

Luke Cook

Dorian Gray

Luke Schuck

Sami

Patrick McHenry-Kroetch

Sheir

James Sweet

Adel

Ben Andrews

Brad

Daniel Brockley

Amos

Rick Espaillat

Doctor

Robin Douglas

Nurse

Foss Curtis

Paramedic

Jon Bebe

Hawkins

Gary Norman

Professor

Ulric Dihle

Screener

Gary Powell

Diplomat

Tricia Helfer

Karen Willis

Tyler Mane

Minotaur

Sean McGrath

Mr. Franklin

Sonya Davis

Jennie

Mathew Bostrom

Henry Birch

Jim Jefferies

British Santa

Cathy Vu

Paramedic Glover

Tim Gouran

Ian

Paul Root

Pilot

Paul F. Bernard

Barkeep

Cary-Hiroyuki Tagawa

Mr. Drake

Naia Schroder

Lady Sylalandria of the Fae Legions

Jimmy Garcia

Dobra

Natsuko Abrams

Akemi

Kei Sugimoto

Haruki

Carey Gosa

Dragon (voice)

René Auberjonois

Mr. McGuire

Ted Rooney

Sheriff Heyer

Sophia Mitri Schloss

Jamie

Eric Ray Anderson

Walter

Kate Alden

Liza

Aparna Brielle

Flirty Waitress

Gary Kraus

Naked Mayor

Chrisse Roccaro

Arguing Woman

Brendan Quinlan

Arguing Man

Alicia Witt

Lucinda McCabe / Morgan le Fay

Bex Taylor-Klaus

Amy Meyer

Amy Farrington

Amy's Mother

Jacob Bean-Watson

Dashell

Christina Ferrari

Olivia

Maxwell Chase

Leonard

Katie Norton

Elysse

Billy Boudavong

Tim

Tom Dang

Jonah

Joshua Jérard

Zahir

Sam Kamerman

Sarah

Stephen Kelsey

Kindly Gentleman

Haley Webb

Mabel Collins

Robynn Hayek

Diner Waitress

Aaron Blakely

Marco

Amin El Gamal

Apep

Austin Hillebrecht

Photographer

Ayanna Berkshire

Dr. Njenga

Benjamin Flores Jr.

Freddy

Beth Riesgraf

Lady of the Lake

Bob Newhart

Judson

Brady Rubin

Older Mrs. Cathy Worth

Brent Spiner

Puck (voice)

Brice Fisher

Young Kirby

Buster Reeves

The Reaper

Cara Mitsuko

Tech

Christopher D. Harder

Guard #3

Christopher Heyerdahl

Grigori Yefimovich Rasputin

Clara Lago

Estrella

Dan Considine

Griz

Dana Green

Sergeant Reuben

Darius Pierce

Finklestein

David Meyers

Interpol Agent

David S. Lee

Moriarty

David Ury

William Shakespeare

Delpaneaux Wills

Attendant

Drew Powell

Ray / Spirit of the Library

Edward Stiner

Chess Player

Efka Kvaraciejus

Dimitry

Elisha Henig

Vern

Emily Kimball

Lindsey Harris

Emily Sahler

Sylvia

Eric Newsome

Mailman Dave

Erica Sullivan

Fairy

Felicia Day

Charlotte

Ginifer King

Meredith

Gray Eubank

Vernon

Greg Sproles

Ivan

Hailee Keanna Lautenbach

Woman #3

Hank Cartwright

Sheriff

Hannah Barefoot

Kelly Nelson

Hayley McLaughlin

Ariel

Ian Bell

Bart Hoskins

J.J. Johnston

General Uriah Loveday

J.P. Manoux

Preacher / Dradok / Bartender

Jane Curtin

Charlene

Jayne Taini

Agnes

Jean-Luc Boucherot

Pierre

Jeb Berrier

Mr. Tanner

Jeff Fahey

Isaac Stone

Jen Rowe

Researcher

Jeremiah Birkett

Agent Tannen

Jerry Bell Jr.

Worker

Jerry O'Connell

Lancelot du Lac (uncredited)

Joe Ross

Carstairs

John de Lancie

Sesselman

John J. Joseph

Victor Finch / Norman

John Noble

Monsignor Vega

Julia Prud'homme

Sheriff Macready

Julian Acosta

Adamski

Kasha Kropinski

Lucy Lyons

Kathy Hsieh

Shhhhhh Woman

Keith Cox

Rager General

Kevin T. Williams

Andy

Lorraine Bahr

Penelope

Lowell Deo

NASA Official

Matt Frewer

Dulaque

Matt Lasky

Colin

Matt Nolan

Jefferson Keating

Michael Gladis

Frankenstein's Monster

Michael Trucco

Sam Denning

Michelle Lee

Major Domo

Natasha Ward

Guard #2

Nathan Woodworth

Student

Nicole McCullough

Young Charlotte

Nina Seničar

Isabella

Norma Maldonado

Sofia

Orianna Milne

Madeline Kincaid

Patricia Ferguson

Charity Jones

Rachael Perrell Fosket

Cindy Kroger

Rachel Nichols

Nicole Noone

Rafael Cebrian

Tomas

Razaaq Adoti

Doorman

Renato Solpietro

Mourner

Rich Morris

Dirk as Mac

Richard Cox

Prospero

Richard Kind

Bennie Konopka

Rob Nagle

Barry

Robert Pescovitz

Professor Roger Bancroft

Sean Astin

The Amazing Mysterium / Kirby

Shannon Day

Hotel Clerk

Shawn Law

Troy

Sherri Saum

Karla

Skyler Verity

Graham

Sunny Mabrey

Fortuna

Susannah Mars

Group Leader

Ted Douglass

Restaurant Patron

Tee Dennard

Townsfolk #1

Timothy Eulich

DOSA Guard

Todd A. Robinson

Roach Peters

Tony Doupe

Tony Schazzola

Usman Ally

Security Lt. Becker

Vanessa Williams

Cynthia Rockwell

William Morgan Sheppard

Teddy Chislington