Peter Thomas

Self - Narrator (voice)

James E. Ash

David Copenhefer (uncredited)

Jennifer Granholm

Self - Michigan Attorney General (archive footage)

M. William Phelps

Self - True Crime Author, 'Cruel Death'

John Walsh

Self

Frank Bender

Self

Trey Gowdy

Self

Roy Shuler

Wilson Saintil · Suspect (uncredited)

Danni Lang

Christina Sanoubane

William J. White

Carlos Robinson

Ruben Fischman

Detective Duncan

Dave Weidler

Jeffrey Flynn

Lisa Kobak

Ken's Collegue

Edgar Felix

Detective Spinelli

JaQuinley Kerr

Ashley Wallace

Gene Hansen

Tom Mulcahy

Natalie Stavola

Surviving Victim

Craig Chamberlin

Lineup Guy

Kaia Foss

Christine Paolilla

Shane Hartline

Restaurant Patron

Jon Douglas Rainey

Detective

Nicholas Barrera

Juan Sanchez

Amy Fox

Ex-Girlfriend

Jessica Alexandra Green

Summer Baldwin

Bettina Mangiaracina

Joanna Rogers

Denise Parella

Michele

Jarret Janako

Lonnie Jr.

Phil. E. Eichinger

Rudy Gaytan

Jade Froeder

Renee Dulaney

Damian Muziani

Eddie Makdessi

Victor Gunnarsson

Self