Chris Evans

Andy Barber

Jaeden Martell

Jacob Barber

Michelle Dockery

Laurie Barber

Cherry Jones

Joanna Klein

Pablo Schreiber

Neal Logiudice

J.K. Simmons

Billy Barber

Daniel Henshall

Leonard Patz

Betty Gabriel

Pam Duffy

Sakina Jaffrey

Lynn Canavan

Jordan Alexa Davis

Sarah Grohl

Ben Taylor

Derek Yoo

Poorna Jagannathan

Elizabeth Vogel

Tamara Hickey

Toby

Hale Lytle

Matt McGrath

Maria Elena Ramirez

Cara

Ted Arcidi

Kingston

Liam Kilbreth

Ben Rifkin

Shawn Fitzgibbon

Detective Peterson

William Xifaras

Father O'Leary

Devon Diep

Reiko

Cheryl McMahon

Mrs. Mandel

Daryl Edwards

Judge French

Therese Plaehn

Lita McGrath

Myra Lucretia Taylor

Judge Rivera

Aaron Andrade

Mr. Fuller

Shannon Ashe

Christine

Alfred Briere

Molloy

Gene Dante

Ian

Mai Delapa

Katie

Frankie Francois

Sienna

Rebecca Gibel

Wendy

Gary Kirby

Older Man

Collin Knight

Police Officer

Ian Lyons

Burt Knox

Melissa McMeekin

Roxanne

Michele Proude

Court Clerk

Carrie Ann Quinn

Kathleen

Odis Spencer

Principal

Angela Hope Smith

Molloy's Counsel

Patrick Fischler

Dan Rifkin

Megan Byrne

Joan Rifkin

Raymond Alongi

Park Ranger

Rebekah Curtis-Motley

Cashier

Michael Jibrin

Detective Freeman

Sarah McLean

Female Officer

Daniel Washington

Officer at Trailhead

Sam Zephir

Officer #1

Tom Mariano

Walpole Prison Guard

Tobias Wilson

CPAC Trooper

Phoenix Curcuru

Phoebe

Audrey Wasilewski

Jeanine

Caralyn Aufiero

Waitress

Evan Risser

6-Year-Old Andy

Kallie Tabor

Kirsten

Lizzie Short

Andy's Mom

Austin J. Ryan

Lacrosse Kid

Hannah Yun

Dina Yoo

Mariko Kanto

Waitress

Jim Boyd

Reporter at Courthouse

Marilyn Busch

Court Clerk

Ken Cheeseman

Rod Renborg

Berlis Cuevas

Bailiff

Rena Maliszewski

Karen Carlson

Damon Singletary

Bartender

Michael Tow

Reporter

Michelle Violette

Paula Gianetto

Stephanie Bisono

Nurse

Jessi Case

Hope Connors

Chelsea Hueter

Reporter

Charles Coan

Search Party Participent (uncredited)