Evan Peters

Jeffrey Dahmer

Richard Jenkins

Lionel Dahmer

Molly Ringwald

Shari Dahmer

Michael Learned

Catherine Dahmer

Niecy Nash

Glenda Cleveland

Brey Chanadet

Other Kid

Nick Fisher

Young Jeffrey Dahmer

Michael Beach

Det. Dennis Murphy

Colby French

Patrick Kennedy

Mac Brandt

Robert Rauth

Shaun Brown

Tracy Edwards

Grant Harvey

Rolf Mueller

Penelope Ann Miller

Joyce Dahmer

Kieran Tamondong

Konerak Sinthasomphone

Josh Braaten

Young Lionel Dahmer

Cameron Cowperthwaite

Steven Hicks

Nigel Gibbs

Reverend Jesse Jackson

Justin Stella

Derek

Andy Taylor Kim

Investigator

Ken Lerner

Joe Zilber

Savannah Brown

Young Joyce Dahmer

Michael Andrew Baker

Lionel's Lawyer

Jesse Bush

Officer #1

Thomas Crawford

Judge

Colin Ford

Chazz

Karole Foreman

Dottie

Asa Germann

Blonde Jogger

Matthew Gilmore

Officer #2

Trilby Glover

Guidance Counselor

Alex Hyde-White

Doctor

Emma Kennedy

Denise

Peter MacKenzie

Mr. Bertoglio

Tenz McCall

Young David Dahmer

David Theune

Math Teacher

Ato Blankson-Wood

Aaron

Chris Gann

Police Officer #1

Rhoyle Ivy King

Don

Joshua Edward Moore

CSI Investigator

Mark Reininga

Young Police Officer

Leanne Suter

On Camera Reporter

Matthew Alan

Officer Gabrish

Scott Michael Morgan

Officer Balcerzak

Hope Banks

Mrs. Hempsill

Rodney Burford

Tony Hughes

Cole Capps

Kevin

Ken Clement

Wally the Butcher

Tyler Crim

Paramedic #2

Tempany Deckert

Front Desk Police Officer

Peter Holden

Police Officer

Daniel Curtis Lee

Police Photographer

Keylor Leigh

Department Store Clerk

Travon McCall

Police Lieutenant

Dia La Ren Nash

Sandra Smith

Curtis Nelson II

Paramedic #1

Teshi Thomas

Nicole Childress

Vince Hill-Bedford

Steven Tuomi

Blake Cooper Griffin

Charles

Mark Atteberry

Dr. Park Dietz - Psychologist

Hollie Bahar

Field Surgeon

Fiona Bishop

Yearbook Girl

Aaron Coleman

Dean of Students

Bill Doyle

Special Agent

Brie Eley

Clinician

Isaac Faulkner

Dan

Michael Germant

Seth

Brittany Giles

Tina

Steve Hasley

Photographer

John Ahle Kellar

Doug Brozovsky

Eugene Ko

Yearbook Guy

Teddy Margas

Sticky Ricky

Collie Jay Simmons

Bartender

Carson Zone

Tanner

Dyllón Burnside

Ronald Flowers

Benjahmin Svyatoslavich

Anthony Sears

Matt Cordova

Detective Rauss

Jamela Asha

Stenographer

Skyler Bible

Richard Guerrero

Ivar Brogger

Judge

Ron Bush

Jeffery’s Lawyer

Crystal Coney

Nurse

Adam Dunnells

White Prisoner

Adwin Brown

Dennis

Amanda Reed

Linda

Anissa Borrego

Cashier

Antonio David Lyons

Pastor

Ariella Amar

Checkout Woman

Arthur Richardson

Manager

Arye Gross

Gerald Boyle

Austin Cauldwell

Rick

Ava Ticotin

Janie Hagen

Ben Scott

Bus Driver

Bill Chott

MPA President

Brandon Black

Dean Vaughn

Brandon Papo

Male Employee

Britt George

Portage Prison Guard #3

Bruce Beatty

Dr. Larry Weeks

Carlos Arellano

Bailiff

Chase Fein

Police Officer #2

Cheryl Francis Harrington

Shirley’s Mother

Chris Greene

Chaplain Adams

Christopher Bencomo

Manny

Clark Moore

Deputy Chief

Danny Max

Fresno Reporter #3

David Barrera

Chief Arreola

David Bowe

Russell Goldstein

David Kelsey

Robert Fennig, Attorney

Demián Castro

Geraldo Rivera

Dominic Burgess

John Wayne Gacy

Doug Long

Officer #2

Eric Normington

Gavin

Ericka Kreutz

Female Sergeant

Eva La Dare

Delivery Nurse

Furly Mac

Christopher Scarver

Horace Gold

Isaac Richards

J. Paul Boehmer

Larry King

Jackson Hurst

Stone Phillips

Jacob Chattman

Paul Myers

Jake Green

Officer Kelly

Jay Jackson

Newscaster

Jeff Harms

Jesse Anderson

Jim McCaffree

Sheriff - 1957

John Grady

Barry Goldman

John Shartzer

Marcus

Jonathan Stanley

Officer Krause

Jordan Wall

Darryl

Karen Malina White

Shirley Hughes

Karl Makinen

Officer Clyde Reynolds

Keanush Tafreshi

Denim Employee #1

Khetphet Phagnasay

Sounthone Sinthasomphone

Kiff VandenHeuvel

Frank Currier

Kyle Butenhoff

Ron

Kyrsten V. Williams

Kim Hughes

Leroy Edwards III

Osvaldo Durruthy

Linda Park

Julie Yang

Mark Weiler

Officer

Markina Brown

Fresno Reporter #2

Matt Kaminsky

Walter Jacobson

Matthew Downs

Officer Melnick

Mercy Malick

Milwaukee Reporter #2

Michael Adler

Judge Lawrence Gram

Michael Anthony Spady

Rufus

Molly Baker

Audience Member

Nicole Lynn Evans

Prison Librarian

Nikea Gamby-Turner

Mildred Lindsey

Noel Arthur

Doctor

Olivia Baptista

Margaret

Patrick Day

Chaplain Berkum

Paul Zies

Tattooed Prisoner

Phet Mahathongdy

Somdy Sinthasomphone

Phil Biedron

Portage Prison Guard

Rachel Winfree

Woman

Raphael Sbarge

Mayor John Norquist

Raymond Watanga

Sopa Princewill

Rodney J. Hobbs

African American Sergeant

Rosemary Thomas

Catherine Straughter

Roslyn Gentle

Coroner

Sarah Chang

Emily Soo

Scott Broderick

Warden Jeff Endicott

Scott Thomas Reynolds

Police Officer #2

Serene Branson

News Correspondent

Shane Kerwin

Ed Gein

Spencer Squire

Nick

Stephanie Erb

Susan

Taneka Johnson

Pediatrics Nurse

Tom Virtue

Father Hecker

Tony Robinette

Donald Bradehoft

Troy Blendell

Roy Ratcliffe

Verton R. Banks

Larry King