Nathan Wiley

Narrator (voice)

Cherise Silvestri

Narrator (voice)

Russell Bentley

Narrator (voice)

Rachel Rain Packota

Razakel

Chandler Boriska

Melanie Wells

Jason C. Paul

Sam

Raina Harten

Amanda

Victoria Yau

Carol

Alyson MacFarlane

Avery

Sammy Jo Higgins

Kayleigh

Blake Canning

Aaron

Linnea Currie-Roberts

Nichole Cable

Maarika Pinkney Freund

Kristine Wiley (Nichole's Mom)

Marcus McKinley

Kyle Dube

Todd Perry

Detective Smith

Mandi Nicholson

Harleigh Robertson

Sonya Proehl

Sarah Mason (Kyle's Girlfriend & Bryan's Ex)

Brandon Wilson

Bryan Butterfield

Staci Bouskill

Teresa McBain

Stephanie Valano

Marcy

Jeremy Durgana

Detective

Aveleigh Keller

Kacie Woody

Shawn Devlin

Rick Woody

Sidney Sholdice

Jessica Bradford

Kye Deuters

Scott

Curtis Desrosiers

Lt. Jim Barrett

Jamie Tarantini

Amanda Howard

Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi

Self - ADA, Brooklyn, NY

Suzanne Pratley

Kathleen

Brendan Nasr

Alex

Halle Tator

Samantha Chonski

Emily Frye

Ashley Reynolds

Maggie Garrison

Elizabeth Shubert

Merritt Crews

Angela Reynolds

James Coburn

Special Agent Meyer

Jay Kee

Sam Dreher

Jenna Harris

Danielle Dreher

Brian McDonald

Detective Chad McDonald

Kunta Murange

Michael Minor

Alyssa Goodridge

Jasmin Nuñez

Orville Cummings

Andres Ceballos

Celine Baumans

Melanie Nuñez

Wanda Crosta

Denise Suarez

Pamela Archer

Iris

Mason Cromwell

Det. Terence Munnelly

Gloria Allred

Self (archive footage)

Madeleine Wiedmer

Autumn Pasquale

Alexandera Yetman

Barb DeFrance (Family Friend)

Joseph JR Yeboah

Dante Robinson

Diana Goldman

Leslie Belkin

Red Carlsen

George Lamp

Paige Torch

Rachel Belkin

Drew Riedstra

Major Campbell

Veronique Auger-Drolet

Renee Blanchard

Dawn Sadler

Anne Simenson

Jay Brown

Mike Lamp

Brooke Samms

Megan Meier

Cheryl Poirier

Tina Meier

Avery Laine

Christina 'Chrissy' Long

Greg Zajac

Ron Meier

Kim Lores

Lori Drew

Katie Dewling

Sarah Drew

Dylan Worth

Blaine Buckles

Margaret Evraire

Jessica Sacco

Randy Starr

Joe Nick (Missing Persons Investigator)

Timothy Hedden

Chris

Jim Canale

Glenn Kallai

Patrick McFadden

Matthew Puccio

Adam Martignetti

Andrew Forney

John Phillips

Chris Wright

Will Conlon

Wade Ridley

Stephen Davis

Scott Davis

Richard Crossman

Jack aka Richard Beasley

Thomas Brouwer

Brogan Rafferty

Ian Awerbuck

David Pauley

Julia Flood

Ashley Smith / Lauren Gash

Sarah Jean Hodkinson

Alisa Betts

Sarah Lynn Strange

Jeana Booth, Amanda's Mom

Jason Bigio

Officer Brandon Shrout

John Laughlin

Detective Troy Pharr