Jessica Biel

Candy Montgomery

Melanie Lynskey

Betty Gore

Pablo Schreiber

Allan Gore

Timothy Simons

Pat Montgomery

Raúl Esparza

Don Crowder

Jessie Mueller

Sherry Cleckler

Coley Campany

Linda

Sharon Conley

Sandra Lockett

Aven Lotz

Becky Montgomery

Dash McCloud

Jason Montgomery

Justin Timberlake

Deputy Steve Deffibaugh (uncredited)

Russell Thomas

Jeffery Lockett

Jason Ritter

Deputy Denny Reese

Jamie Anne Allman

Elaine

Sunkrish Bala

Sid

Adam Bartley

Richard

Bruce McKinnon

Jerry

Antonella Rose

Christina Gore

Jose Miguel Vasquez

Lester Gayler

Lauren Halperin

Tommy

Luis R. Hernandez

Allan's Boss

Sara Lynn Holbrook

Waitress

Alex Mitchell

DFW Bank Teller

Jordan Patrick

Reverend Ron

Billie Roy

Kimmy

Daniel Pransky

Desk Clerk

Hudson Hughes

Davey

Selena Anduze

Jackie Ponder

Tim Ware

Judge Ryan

Preston James Hillier

Chuck

Robert Mello

Earl

Peyton Waldrep

Girl

Jason Davis

Jack Barton

Liz McGeever

Mary Lou Barton

Jesse Gallegos

Robert Udashen

Annie Cook

Mrs. Pomeroy

Elisabeth Lewis Corley

Don's Mother

Rick Espaillat

Bob Pomeroy

Jack Landry

Tom Cleckler

Shaun Lynch

Deputy Dave

Aaron K Smalls

News Anchor

Norio Nishimura

ADA Schultz

Jayson Warner Smith

DA O'Connell

Kathrine Barnes

Mother

Madison Bello

Young Candy

Mallory Hoff

Journalist

Javier Vazquez Jr.

Jury Foreman

Tom Warner

Psychiatrist