Sean Giambrone

Jimmy McGill (voice)

Kyle S. More

Marco Pasternak (voice)

Zac Palladino

Trent's Mom (voice)

Brian Sommer

Taxi Driver / Radio Host / Trent-alike 1 (voice)

Carlos Alazraqui

Cheech / Comic store worker / Trent-alike 2 (voice)

Jasmine Gatewood

Female Trent-alike-2 (voice)

Will Vought

Trent Titweiler (voice)

Chi McBride

Father Karras (voice)

Laraine Newman

Sister Beth (voice)

David Herman

Roger / Warren / Seth (voice)

Beth Grant

Mrs. Brockfrater (voice)

Gideon Adlon

Dawn Marie (voice)

Gary Anthony Williams

Demon (voice)