Kathryn Hahn

Agnes O'Connor / Agatha Harkness

Joe Locke

Teen

Sasheer Zamata

Jennifer Kale

Ali Ahn

Alice Wu-Gulliver

Debra Jo Rupp

Mrs. Hart

Patti LuPone

Lilia Calderu

Aubrey Plaza

Rio Vidal

Emma Caulfield

Dottie

David Payton

Herb

David Lengel

Jones

Asif Ali

Norm

Amos Glick

Dennis the Mailman

Elaine Valdes

Customer #1

Paria Akbarshahi

Customer #2

Chau Naumova

Salem Seven / Coyote

Bethany Curry

Salem Seven / Crow

Athena Perample

Salem Seven / Fox

Alicia Vela-Bailey

Salem Seven / Owl

Britta Grant

Salem Seven / Rat

Marina Mazepa

Salem Seven / Snake

Elizabeth Anweis

Lorna Wu

Chloe Camp

Young Lilia

Laura Boccaletti

Lilia's Maestra

Scott Butler

The Doctor

Jade Quon

The Demon

Kate Forbes

Evanora Harkness

Maria Dizzia

Rebecca Kaplan

Paul Adelstein

Jeff Kaplan

Miles Gutierrez-Riley

Eddie

Evan Peters

Ralph Bohner

James Bostick

EMT

Erica Frene

Event Planner

Alexandria Shuval-Weiner

Rabbi Levin

Okwui Okpokwasili

Salem Seven / Vertigo

Abel Lysenko

Nicholas Scratch

Hannah Lowther

Forest Witch

Tetra Lloyd

Singing Forest Witch

Henriette Zoutomou

Village Witch

Holly Bonney

Tavern Witch

Kim Bass

Young Witch