Katherine Heigl

Stephanie Plum

Jason O'Mara

Joseph Morelli

Daniel Sunjata

Ranger

John Leguizamo

Jimmy Alpha

Sherri Shepherd

Lula

Debbie Reynolds

Grandma Mazur

Patrick Fischler

Vinnie Plum

Harry O'Toole

William Earling

Debra Monk

Mrs. Plum

Nate Mooney

Eddie Gazarra

Adam Paul

Bernie Kuntz

Fisher Stevens

Morty Beyers

Ana Reeder

Connie

Ryan Michelle Bathe

Jackie

Leonardo Nam

John Cho

Annie Parisse

Mary Lou

Danny Mastrogiorgio

Lenny

Gavin-Keith Umeh

Benito Ramirez

Lisa Ann Goldsmith

Police Woman

David Early

Carmen's Neighbor

Louis Mustillo

Mr. Plum

Jackson Nunn

Criminal (uncredited)

Marla Sucharetza

Sunny

Angela Pietropinto

Mama Morelli

Jack Erdie

Flat Nose Louis

Jake Andolina

Cop #1

Joshua Elijah Reese

Cop #2

Tommy Lafitte

Locksmith

Olga Merediz

Rosa Gomez

Michael Laurence

Lonnie Dodd

Jared Burke

Struggling FTA

Jarrod DiGiorgi

Ziggy Kuleska

David Flick

Sal

Jared Pfennigwerth

Darren