Judy Greer

Grace

Pete Holmes

Bob

Molly Belle Wright

Beth

Beatrice Schneider

Imogene

Sebastian Billingsley-Rodriguez

Charlie

Matthew Lamb

Claude

Essek Moore

Ollie

Kirk B.R. Woller

Reverend Hopkins

Ewan Wood

Leroy

Mason D Nelligan

Ralph

Kynlee Heiman

Gladys

Lauren Graham

Adult Beth (voice)

Stanlee Arches

Ticket Taker

Vanessa Benavente

First Grade Teacher

Mariam Bernstein

Mrs. Armstrong

Jenni Burke

Miss Graebner

Kamal Chioua

Joseph

Lauren Cochrane

Nurse Pond

Sarah Constible

Mrs. Slocum

Wyatt Dewar

David

Joshua Downes

Kid in Class

Zoe Fish

Choir Kid #1

Donna Fletcher

Piano Player

Sara Angelica Lopez Garcia

Mary Mother

Davison Gee

Robby

Nolan Grantham

Elmer Hopkins

Danielle Hoetmer

Mrs. Wendelken

Adam Hurtig

Mr. Grady

Maisy Jacques

Choir Kid #6

Kincade Johnson

Choir Kid #4

Reena Jolly

Ms. Warren

Kevin Klassen

Male Parent

Daina Leitold

Mrs. Hopkins

Owen Mathison

Choir Kid #5

Shantaya Labiuk

Choir Kid #8

Chloe McKinnon

Little One

Curtis Moore

TV Announcer

Lorelei Olivia Mote

Alice

Anastasia Rautert

Choir Kid #9

Ray Strachan

Fireman

Stephanie Sy

Mrs. Thomas

Elizabeth Tabish

Mrs. Grady

Isla Verot

Becky

Tom Young

George Armstrong