Zach Braff

Aidan Bloom

Kate Hudson

Sarah Bloom

Joey King

Grace Bloom

Mandy Patinkin

Gabe

Ashley Greene

Janine

Josh Gad

Noah Bloom

Jim Parsons

Paul

Michael Weston

Jerry

Pierce Gagnon

Tucker Bloom

Alexander Chaplin

Rabbi Rosenberg

Leslie David Baker

Audition Actor #1

James Avery

Audition Actor #2

Ato Essandoh

Audition Actor #3

Mark Thudium

Terry

Allan Rich

Rabbi Twersky

Cody Sullivan

Jesse

Bruce Nozick

Dr. Becker

Matt Winston

Alan

Taylor Bagley

Janine's Friend

Jennifer Terry

Janine's Other Friend

Jackie Johnson

Female Supermarket Employee

Bob Clendenin

Defense Attorney

Silvia Curiel

Esperanza

Nichole Galicia

Juliet

Andrew Anderson

Reaper (uncredited)

Bill Blair

Marching Captain (uncredited)

Donald Faison

Anthony

Max Wright

Jewish Choir Boy