Jared Harris

Stan Deen

Nicholas Hamilton

Nathan Williams

Jamie Harris

Barney

Sasha Bhasin

Tina Baxter

Will Price

Johnny Alecco

Kimberly S. Fairbanks

Deborah May

Tobias Segal

Nate's Father

Martin Jarvis

Henry V (voice)

Brandon Miles

Barnaby

Johnathan Davis

Officer Smits

Daisy Galvis

Judge

Scottie DiGiacomo

Mother

Banks Quinney

Young Nathan

Elise Hudson

Linda

Meredith Sullivan

Gloria

Niva Patel

Jen

Gwyneth Anne Trumbore

Orphan

Shannon Destiny Ryan

Young Woman Annabel

Searra Sawka

Rona

Ava Wrubel

Pastor's Daughter

Sung Yoon

Carl

Kiley Lotz

Sandy

Cole Tristan Murphy

Noah

Chris James Boylan

Blake

Carol Florence

Nanny Cole

Rachel Poletick

Terry

Collin Roach

Travis

L. J. Moses

Cellmate

Kathy Patterson

Older Woman

Lauren LoGiudice

Attorney

Ernest DiLullo Sr.

Prison Guard

Kendra Mittermeyer

Neighbor

Cole Flanders

Orphan

Phillip Chorba

Tom Friedman

Susanne Sulby

Mariam Baker

Vann Barrett

Booking Officer

Joey Cabrera

Jim Baxter

Madalyn St. John

Mrs. Feeney

Pat DeFusco

Principal Larson

Madeleine Garcia

Lisa

Chuck Pressler

Paramedic #1

Michael Jansen

Officer Spellen

Gina Jun

Nurse (uncredited)

Tim R. Worley

Parent (uncredited)