Freddie Prinze Jr.

Ryan Walker

Claire Forlani

Jennifer Burrows

Jason Biggs

Hunter / Steve

Amanda Detmer

Amy

Alyson Hannigan

Betty

Brendon Ryan Barrett

Young Ryan Walker

Gay Thomas Wilson

N.Y. Flight Attendant

Raquel Beaudene

Young Jennifer Burrows

David Smigelski

Homecoming King

Blake Shields

Homecoming Knight

Sean Maysonet

Michael

Tsianina Joelson

Girl in Bar

Kristofer Mickelson

Big Guy

Matt Carmody

Kirt

Heather Donahue

Megan

Richard Hillman

Frat Guy

Tim Griffin

Timmy

Timi Prulhiere

Andi

Eric Rutherford

Noah

Matt Schulze

Paul

Monica

Katie

Angela Oh

Waitress

Brian Poth

Guy in Diner

Mimi Rose

Girl in Diner

David Correia

Shuttle Driver

Lisa Eichhorn

Suttle Passenger

Lee Garlington

L.A. Flight Attendant

John Henry Redwood

Businessman

Barbara Spiegel

Saleswoman

Kylie Bax

Supermodel

Kristy Hinze

Supermodel

Ines Rivero

Supermodel

Renate Verbaan

Supermodel

Susan Kellermann

Therapist

Timothy Anderson

Dancer

Bryan Anthony

Dancer

Sybil Azur

Dancer

Albee Bautista

Dancer

Dominic Carbone

Dancer

Linda Cevallos

Dancer